16 November 2026
Sanctions Clauses in Charterparties: Are Standard Clauses Enough?
Members and assureds may already be aware of the Court of Appeal of England & Wales case of “The Catalan Sea” Tonzip Maritime (Singapore) Pte Ltd v 2 Rivers Pte Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 641, where a bespoke sanctions clause in a charterparty was considered to give owners a wide discretion to refuse employment orders which, “in the reasonable judgement of the owners, is prohibited by sanctions or will expose the owners, the vessel or its managers, crew, the vessel’s insurers or reinsurers to sanctions”.
English lawyers, HFW, have recently issued a briefing discussing a recent unreported London arbitration case in which the sanctions clause used was the BIMCO Sanctions Clause for Time Charter Parties 2020, and whether it protects owners against future sanctions exposure arising from the risk of designation under modern sanctions regimes.
The issue arose in the context of a voyage to Cuba following the introduction of US Executive Order 14404, which authorises the designation of certain persons operating in, or supporting, specified sectors of the Cuban economy. Significantly, the Executive Order does not automatically designate all persons falling within its criteria. Instead, a separate determination by the US authorities is required before sanctions apply. As a result, parties dealing with such entities may face a risk of future designation or secondary sanctions exposure, even where no current sanctions prohibition exists.
The arbitration considered whether owners could refuse charterers' orders to discharge in Cuba on the basis that the consignee and/or port operator might expose the owners to sanctions risk. The tribunal drew a clear distinction between the wording of the standard BIMCO clause, and the bespoke sanctions clause considered by the Court of Appeal in “The Catalan Sea”.
In "The Catalan Sea", the clause entitled owners to reject orders where, in their reasonable judgment, compliance would expose them or associated parties to sanctions. By contrast, the BIMCO clause is drafted more narrowly and prohibits only orders involving a "Sanctioned Party" or a "Sanctioned Activity", both of which require an actual designation or existing sanctions prohibition. The tribunal concluded that a perceived or theoretical risk of future designation is insufficient to engage the clause.
The case is a timely reminder to those negotiating charterparties to consider whether additional protections are required in their charterparty wording. Members and assureds are encouraged to review their sanctions clauses and consider using standard sanctions clauses as a starting point, so that further amendments and additional clauses can be added and tailored to their specific risk appetite, trading patterns and to protect them from sanctions exposure.
Further information
BIMCO has several different standard clauses addressing sanctions: for time charterparties, voyage charteparties, container vessels 2021, COAs 2022 and for Russian Oil Price Cap Scheme 2024. For more information > Sanctions